Bumblly

DocMint guide

How to black out text in a PDF so it is really gone

You drew a black box over a name in a PDF and sent it. It looks safe. But in many PDFs the name is still there, under the box, and anyone can copy it out. Here is why, how to check a file yourself, and what really removes the text.

We make DocMint, an app that redacts PDFs on iPhone, iPad and Android. Most of this guide applies to any app.

The problem

Why a black box hides nothing

A PDF stores words as text. That is why you can search a PDF and copy from it. A rectangle or a thick black highlight drawn on top is a separate shape. It covers the words on screen, but the words stay in the file. Copy and paste, a search, or another PDF app can bring them back.

The American Bar Association's Judges' Journal described a well-known case. In January 2019, lawyers for Paul Manafort filed a PDF in a US federal court with passages under black boxes. People copied the text into another document and the hidden passages appeared. The column names two likely causes: text that was highlighted black in a word processor before it became a PDF, or black rectangles drawn over the text in the PDF (The Judges' Journal).

Hidden places

Where else private data hides in a PDF

Adobe makes the same point from the other side: redaction removes visible text and graphics, and hidden data such as metadata or embedded content has to be removed separately (Adobe Help). Things to think about:

Check

How to check a PDF before you send it

If a covered word shows up in any of these, the box did not remove it.

Solutions

What really removes the text

DocMint

How DocMint does it

DocMint rewrites the page: the letters under each box are taken out of the page itself, and pictures under a box are painted over. It then saves a new PDF built from the pages only, so metadata and attached files do not come along. When it cannot place a font's letters exactly, it turns that page into a picture with the boxes painted in, and tells you which pages it flattened.

  1. Import the PDF into DocMint. Tap Import, then Import PDF.
  2. Open Redact. Open the document and tap Redact in the row of tools under the page.
  3. Drag boxes over what must go. One box per name, number or picture, on every page where it appears.
  4. Export redacted PDF. DocMint builds a new file and opens the share sheet. The original stays unchanged.
  5. Check it. Search the new file for a word you covered, or copy its text into a note.
An account statement as the original and as the redacted PDF made by DocMint
The original, and the redacted PDF without the covered text.
A bank statement before and after redaction in DocMint: the covered details are gone
A black box alone hides nothing; DocMint removes the text.

Marking areas is free. Exporting a redacted PDF is part of DocMint Pro, which is a one-time Lifetime purchase or a monthly subscription. The store shows the price before you buy.

FAQ

Questions

Is a black highlighter the same as a black box?

Yes, it has the same problem. Both are drawn on top of the text.

Does saving the PDF again remove the text under the box?

Not reliably. When a document with blacked-out text is turned into a PDF, the text can still be there, as in the 2019 case. Always check with search or copy and paste.

Is a scanned document safe?

Only if no recognized text sits under the box. DocMint leaves the recognized text out of every page that has a redaction.

Can DocMint find every place a name appears?

No. You mark each area yourself. Search the document first so you know every place to cover.

Get DocMint

Scan, sign and redact PDFs on your phone

DocMint is free to download. Scanning, text recognition and signing are free; DocMint Pro adds redacted PDF export and exports without the DocMint mark. No account, and your documents stay on your phone.

All DocMint guides · Redact a PDF on iPhone · Redact a PDF on Android · Remove personal data from a PDF

Sources

Sources

We link to the pages behind every statement about another app or platform. They can change after the date we checked them.